<< Chapter < Page | Chapter >> Page > |
Activity | Description | Checklist |
Case Summary | A short, concise summary of your case. This should be more than a translation or paraphrasing of the case. | |
Recapitulation of Competition | A detailed account of the presentation your group gave during the Ethics Bowl that includes the following: (a) a clear, comprehensive, and concise summary of the other team's commentary; (b) an account of how your team responded to the other team's commentary; (c) an itemization of the questions asked and the answers composed by your team during the competition; (d) a reasoned statement of how your group responded to this feedback as well as the scoring of the competition. | |
Refined Analysis | A revised analysis of the case and question that incorporates the other team's commentary and the judge's response. | |
Multiple Viewpoints | A "devil's advocate" section consisting of a clear, full, and strong statement of a position opposed to that of your team's. This could incorporate the comments of the other team and judges or result from your group's own deliberation | |
Reaffirmation and Conclusion | A section defending your group's position against the devil's advocate position and concluding your case analysis. |
Activity | Description | Checklist |
Goal Restatement | Restate the Ethical and Practical Goals that your group developed at the beginning of its formation. | |
Goal Assessment | Provide a careful, documented assessment of your group’s success in meeting these goals. (Don’t just assert that “Our group successfully realized justice in all its activities this semester.” How did your group characterize justice in the context of its work? What specific activities did the group carry out to realize this value? What, among these activities, worked and what did not work? | |
Discussion of Obstacles | Identify obstacles, shortcomings or failures that you group experienced during the semester. How did these arise? Why did they arise? How did you respond to them? Did your response work? What did you learn from this experience? | |
Plan Assessment | Assess the plans you set forth in your initial report on how you intended to realize values and avoid pitfalls. How did these work? Did you stick to your plans or did you find it necessary to change or abandon them in the face of challenges? | |
Procedure Assessment | Discuss your group’s procedures and practices? How did you divide and allocate work tasks? How did you reach consensus on difficult issues? How did you ensure that all members were respected and allowed significant and meaningful participation? What worked and what did not work with respect to these procedures? Will you repeat them in the future? Would you recommend these procedures as best practices to future groups? | |
Lessons Learned | What did you learn from your experience working as a team this semester? What will require further reflection and thought? In other words, conclude your self-evaluation with a statement that summarizes your experience working together as a team this semester |
Notification Switch
Would you like to follow the 'Using the ethics bowl to integrate ethics into the business and professional curriculum' conversation and receive update notifications?