<< Chapter < Page | Chapter >> Page > |
Description | Example | Target of Punishment | Deterrence Trap Avoided? | Non-financial Values Addressed? | Responsive Adjustment | Interference with Corporate Black Box | |
Monetary Exaction | Fines | Pentagon Procurement Scandals | Harms innocent | Fails to Escape | Few or None Targeted | None | No interference |
Stock Dilution | Dilute Stock and award to victim | Stockholders (Not necessarily guilty) | Escapes by attacking future earnings | Few or None | Limited | No interference | |
Probation | Court orders internal changes (special board appointments) | SEC Voluntary Disclosure Program | Corporation and its Members | Escapes since it mandates organizational changes | Focuses on management and subgroup values | Passive adjustment since imposed from outside | Substantial entry into and interference with corporate black box |
Court Ordered Adverse Publicity | Court orders corporation to publicize crime | English Bread Acts (Hester Prynne shame in Scarlet Letter ) | Targets corporate image | Escapes (although adverse publicity indirectly attacks financial values) | Loss of prestige / Corporate shame / Loss of Face/Honor | Active adjustment triggered by shame | No direct interference (corporation motived to restore itself) |
Community Service Orders | Corporation performs services mandated by court | Allied chemical (James River Pollution) | Representative groups/individuals from corporation | Escapes since targets non-financial values | Adds value to community | Passive or no adjustment: sometimes public does recognize that cs is punishment | None |
Notification Switch
Would you like to follow the 'Business ethics' conversation and receive update notifications?