<< Chapter < Page | Chapter >> Page > |
The relevance and likely value of the various consultants' reports, board restructurings, and staff studies were debatable, especially in light of their cost. Fees paid to consultants amounted to approximately $1.6 million during this period, and that figure does not include the opportunity costs of staff time spent on studies and board time spent on by-laws changes. Still, one consultant's study did prove to have a material impact on the Society.
In the summer of 1985, Dr. Bryant C. Tolles, director of museum studies at the University of Delaware, was hired to "make a comprehensive analysis of and report on the society's museum, library, publications, public programming, and education functions." Because of his background, Tolles directed his study toward the care, development, and use of the Society's collections, including their management, conservation, storage, exhibition, and interpretation.
Tolles's report, completed in April 1986, was highly critical of the Society, especially regarding off-site storage of the art collections. In the report, Tolles wrote, "Some particularly fine works of art and historical artifacts are being exposed to an injurious storage environment, and in fact appear to be beyond hope of restoration. ... I can emphatically and succinctly state that the conditions at the rented warehouse in Paterson [New Jersey] are the most blatantly shocking that I have observed during my entire museum career."
In addition to its criticism of the Society's art storage facilities, the Tolles report also outlined numerous other areas in need of attention. In fact, although Tolles clearly recognized the serious implications of invading the endowment and the alarming deficits, his report seemed to separate the Society's extensive physical, personnel, and programmatic shortcomings from their financial implications. In the end, Tolles recommended more than twenty additional positions, ranging from new curators for decorative arts, paper, photos, and prints to new librarians for architecture and maps, along with numerous support staff positions. Program expansions proposed by Tolles included reviving undergraduate and graduate internship programs, expanded publications, extensive public relations campaigns, and the introduction of "hands-on" interactive devices in exhibits, among many others. The costs to fund these new initiatives would be above and beyond the extensive and urgent costs of improved facilities, storage, and security.
Notification Switch
Would you like to follow the 'The new-york historical society: lessons from one nonprofit's long struggle for survival' conversation and receive update notifications?